Re: Small patch for the QNX platform

[Mike Gorchak]

Something goes wrong with 0x0d/0x0a in previous letter. Sorry.

Hello, Ralf!

      >>  This patch adds qnx as platform which supports library version
     information.
      RW>  As far as I can see, this patch changes the versioning scheme 
used on
     QNX.  This means, that potentially all libraries created with libtool
     after this change are incompatible with all of those created before.


No, it is not changes versioning scheme, it adds support for the versioning
under QNX. I did not found any incompatibilities with already compiled and
installed libraries.

      RW>  I see you supplied the last QNX-related change to Libtool, too, 
in
     2004. Can you provide information about why this change is needed now?
     Did QNX change their versioning, or why is this necessary now?


The main problem why I added support for QNX is libdrm, which I porting to
QNX right now, libdrm uses "-version-number 2:4:0", but libtool fails on the
following check:


# Check that each of the things are valid numbers.
case $current in
0|[1-9]|[1-9][0-9]|[1-9][0-9][0-9]|[1-9][0-9][0-9][0-9]|[1-9][0-9][0-9][0-9][0-9]);; *)   func_error "CURRENT \`$current' must be a nonnegative integer"   func_fatal_error "\`$vinfo' is not valid version information"   ;; esacbecause $current is empty at this point. I will mark an error and mycomments to 
the script below with >>>> sign. case $vinfo_number in yes)>>>> if we pass -version-number option to libtool, it sets vinfo_number to"yes".   number_major="$1"   number_minor="$2"   number_revision="$3"   #   # There are really only two kinds -- those that   # 
use the current revision as the major version   # and those that subtract age and use age as   # a minor version.  But, then there is irix   # which has an extra 1 added just for fun   #   case $version_type in   darwin|linux|osf|windows|none)     func_arith $number_major + $number_minor     current=$func_arith_result     
age="$number_minor"     revision="$number_revision"     ;;   freebsd-aout|freebsd-elf|sunos)     current="$number_major"     revision="$number_minor"     age="0"     ;;   irix|nonstopux)     func_arith $number_major + $number_minor     current=$func_arith_result     
age="$number_minor"     revision="$number_minor"     lt_irix_increment=no     ;;>>>> since QNX is not listed platform and $version_type contains "qnx",>>>> the variables $current, $age and $revision are not set and empty at>>>> this point. So this cause a 
problem with $current check for the>>>> non-negative number and non-digit characters.   esac   ;; no)   current="$1"   revision="$2"   age="$3"   ;; esacRW> Also, we would be extremely interested in seeing testsuite (make -kRW> check) output of Libtool on this system.For the 
first bunch of tests (103) there are 3 was failed, but they arefailed because of using gcc command line instead of QNX's QCC wrapper aroundGCC. QNX uses Dinkumware C++/STL library instead of using GNU stdc++, butg++ searching for the libstdc++ instead of dinkumware libcpp library. Thisproblem could be easily solved by setting 
CC=qcc and CXX=QCC. But it was toolate to specify qcc instead of gcc, because I'm using not fast computer forQNX development and almost of half tests has been completed when found thiserror, running all these tests took a lot of time. But if you need, I couldre-run all test suite with QCC wrapper for C++ without any problem 
:) Logattached. Looks like there are few problems, which are not related to C++. Iwill check them.With best regards, Mike Gorchak.  E-mail: address@hidden