Re: Proposal for resolving Half/Quarter note ambiguity on pure tablature staves (with partial code mod)

[demery]

Historical lute tablature notation had a number of issues to deal with
when it came to indication of rhythm.  Remember that this was the late
renaissance, at a time when the notation was being simplified (see Thomas
Morley, _A Plain and Easy Introductiuon to Practical Music_.

A Composer then had a choice of what note to assign his tactus to.  If the
musical form was in any way trinary (eg, a galliard, or a bransle simple)
it was considered apropriate to use the longer durations which could be
'perfect' (maxima, longa, breve, semi-breve) one unto another.  But if
binaria sufficed, the lesser notes could be taken advantage of,
semi-breve..semifusa; and these had the advantage (to us) of all being
stemed.

Thus, the solution lies in 'reduction'; ie, advise users against the use
of half notes and longer in new composition; transliterations should
employ reduction (eg, half->quarter; quarter->eighth ...).

The odd breve is found in some renaissance lute tablature, it has a stem 
toped by a left-going flag or has a circle (at half-mast).

    \    \    |   /
    |.   \    o   |
    |    |    |   |
___________________
___________________
..


-- 
Dana Emery