Re: midi2ly doesn't respect the --key

[Graham Percival]

Laura Conrad wrote:
> > > > > > "Graham" == Graham Percival <address@hidden> writes:
>
>     Graham> I'm not surprised; MIDI files only specifies the pitch number, not 
> the
>     Graham> actual note (i.e. bes and ais are both note 58).  midi2ly is not
>     Graham> intelligent enough to pick notes out of the same key.  
>
> Then what does the --key feature do?

Oops, sorry.  I confess that I wrote the above without actually having a 
clue.

>  If it doesn't decide that note
> 58 is a bes in F major but an ais in B major, what does it do?

It looks like it _is_ supposed to do that.  There's some code in the 
script that claims to do this, but I'm not certain if it's correct.


Could you construct a minimal example of this problem so I can add it to 
the bug tracker?

- Graham