[Top][All Lists]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

GDP: Pitches

From: Graham Percival
Subject: GDP: Pitches
Date: Wed, 26 Sep 2007 17:31:38 -0700
User-agent: Icedove (X11/20070607)

(Michael: this discussion doesn't greatly influence your own formatting
work on Pitches -- whatever we decide here, those changes still need to
be made.  Other than moving the sections.)

Ok, let's start the other half of real GDP work (two halves: formatting
and rewriting) by examining Pitches.  As always, please examine the docs

- inspirational headword will be reinstated on 1 Jan 2008.
- tables in "Note names in other lanuages" are messed up.  That's a
  formatting change that will be completed soon.
- HTML split.  This is a technical problem that I'm looking for help,
  but that discusion takes place elsewhere.
- need links to LSR; that's on the list for Formatters.

- move Cautionary accidentals into Accidentals.
- move Micro tones into Accidentals.
- do "note names in other lanuages" need anything more than cleaning up
  the tables?  I never use non-Dutch stuff (even though I'm Canadian),
  so I'm not the best judge of this.
- need a @refbugs above the final paragraph of Relative octaves.
- Relative octaves: should we omit the discussion about the default
  value of c' ?  (ie \relative {} )   I believe that this construct is
disliked by some developers and might disappear in the future, so should
we start preparing newbies by never mentioning it?  Or should we simply
list this in the @refbugs section?
- I'm not too happy with Octave check, but I can't think of any specific
  change right now.  Simply add to the list of "rewrite whole
- ditto for Transpose: rewrite whole subsection.
- Key signature: should we move the warning ("accidentals and key
  signatures often confuse new users..." to the top of the page?  Or
omit it entirely, since users are supposed to have read the Learning
Manual?   for that matter, should the warnings in the Tutorial be
beefed up?
- Instrument transposition: might need more explanation about \transpose
  vs. \transposition.

- anything else not in this list.  :)

Pitches is one of the most straightforward sections, so there's
relatively little in this list.  That said, if you don't like anything
in the new Pitches section, please speak up now or forever hold your

- Graham

reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]