Re: Fwd: Re: turning a blind eye to dotted note

[David Kastrup]

Torsten Hämmerle <address@hidden> writes:

> Hi Bernhard,
>
> a cadenza is rhythmically free, no checks, no limits, no rules. So a
> combination of \cadenzaOn and | doesn't make any sense.
>
> Apart from this - in addition to all the other replies - I'd like to
> point out that LilyPond's behaviour (allow note durations to stretch
> out into the next bar) is one of the big advantages compared to much
> more rigid software (Finale, Sibelius, ...).
>
> This tine example shows a tuplet /deliberately/ crossing a barline:
>
> Try to achieve this with any other software (I'm not sure about
> Dorico, though) and you'll see that a lot of tricky tweaking and
> fiddling is needed to get it done.

Seriously?  It's pretty much standard fare for Renaissance music and
early baroque, to the degree that often bar lines are confined to
outside of the staff proper.

-- 
David Kastrup