Re: duration longer than meter?

[Blöchl Bernhard]

A misunderstanding, sorry. Chopin etc was not MY argument. It was one in 
the thread Thomas Morley thankfully referred to
http://lilypond.1069038.n5.nabble.com/turning-a-blind-eye-to-dotted-note-td209224.html
setting me on his "black list". One of many arguments (Thomas Hämmerle, 
correct, not to query:
"Situations like my tuplet example (even with tuplet bracket/beam 
crossing a
barline) can be found in Chopin's works among others, *so notes 
stretching
over barlines are, albeit rare, absolutely possible* and not necessarily 
a
"mistake". "
I know that hangers as I had a student pianist friend as studied (not 
music).
There is an interesting list 
https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/25562/help-with-interpreting-notation-in-chopins-nocturne-op-9-no-2.
There are some more, Tchaikowsky and others, mostly errors of the 
editors!
-------------------

But to repeat and to correct the perspective, my basic question kept 
unanswered and I do not want to repeat vain discussions again, it does 
not make sense!

For short:
Why does not message me lilypond a warning (or something else) if I do 
this?
 \relative c'' {
 d4  cis8  c8  b8. ais8  a  gis
 }

I can work on i. e.
 \relative c'' {
 d4  cis8  c8  b8. ais8  a  gis a b c
 }
No problem for lilypond! That is beyond my understanding, to long and 
fro black list.

That was the start of the thread Thomas Morley referred to above. 
Slightly connected to the question "duration longer than meter?" Isn't 
it?


Regards



Am 03.02.2018 21:22, schrieb Noeck:
> Hi Bernhard,
>
> > refer to examples of Chopin and Tschaikowsky ...
>
> Do you have an example for that?
>
> You can do anything that makes sense in terms of music:
>
> - two voices at the same time may look like more notes than fit the
>   measure (as in the case of this thread).
> - If it is unmetered music, you can use \cadenzaOn … \cadenzaOff
> - If the meter changes without indication, you can \omit the
>   TimeSignature and still have correct measure lengths.
> - If it is a implicit triplet or other tuplets you can use \tuplet or
>   \times.
>
> I have never seen anything that does not fall into these categories.
> Have you?
>
> Best,
> Joram
>
> _______________________________________________
> lilypond-user mailing list
> address@hidden
> https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user