Percussion and tab clefs question

[Menu Jacques]

Hello folks,

When producing a score with notes with all identical MusicXML pitches:

        <pitch>
          <step>C</step>
          <octave>4</octave>
        </pitch>

musicxml2ly and Finale 2014 don’t agree on where to display the notes, see below.

Who is right?

The Lily code is:

    c1 | % 14
    \clef "treble^8" | % 14
    c1 | % 15
    \clef "bass^8" | % 15
    c1 | % 16
    \clef "tab" | % 16
    c1 | % 17
    \clef "tab" | % 17
    c1 \break | % 18

MuseScore is not good in this same test, BTW.

Thanks for your help!

JM

musicxml2ly:

Finale 2014:

MuseScore 2.1.0 or 2.2.1: