Re: Octave 3.1.51 available for ftp

[Thomas Treichl]

dbateman schrieb:
> John W. Eaton wrote:
> > As far as I can tell, fftw functions are only referenced directly in
> > liboctave, so I don't see why you should need to also link the fftw
> > library directly with liboctinterp.  If this is needed for fftw, why
> > is it not also needed for the suitesparse libraries?
>
> Maybe the  Ffftw function is the cause of this. I can't remember whether
> this was made matlab compatible before or after 3.0.0, but if after, then
> this would explain the link issue.

Hallo again,

I'm very slow, but I once again had a look at this problem. The functions that 
are not found when linking liboctinterp.dylib can be found each at the end of 
the following outputs.
For suitesparse I'm using static *.a libraries only because I don't know how to 
build shared ones on MacOSX. For fftw I'm building shared *.dylib libraries only 
which is easy to do. Can this be the origin of this problem?

  Thomas


~/Development/octave $ nm liboctave/pic/oct-fftw.o | grep _fftw
00027250 s __GLOBAL__I__ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev
00000000 a __GLOBAL__I__ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev.eh
00003b70 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii
000275d4 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii.eh
00004de0 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii
000276f4 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii.eh
000038d0 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKdPSt7complexIdEmmii
000275a4 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKdPSt7complexIdEmmii.eh
00004b50 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKfPSt7complexIfEmmii
000276c4 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKfPSt7complexIfEmmii.eh
00003d00 T __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii
00027604 S __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii.eh
00004f70 T __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii
00027724 S __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii.eh
00004710 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
00027664 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
000059c0 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
00027784 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
00004000 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKdPSt7complexIdEiRK10dim_vector
00027634 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKdPSt7complexIdEiRK10dim_vector.eh
00005250 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKfPSt7complexIfEiRK10dim_vector
00027754 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKfPSt7complexIfEiRK10dim_vector.eh
00004880 T __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
00027694 S __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
00005b30 T __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
000277b4 S __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
00001180 T 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKdPSt7complexIdE
00027430 S 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKdPSt7complexIdE.eh
00000960 T 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIdEPS2_
00027400 S 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIdEPS2_.eh
00000010 T __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE
00027368 S __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE.eh
00000000 T __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodEv
00000000 A __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodEv.eh
000026d0 T __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC1Ev
000274c8 S __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC1Ev.eh
000020d0 T __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev
00027490 S __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev.eh
00000140 T 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKfPSt7complexIfE
000273d0 S 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKfPSt7complexIfE.eh
000018c0 T 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIfEPS2_
00027460 S 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIfEPS2_.eh
000000a0 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE
0002739c S __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE.eh
00000090 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodEv
00000000 A __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodEv.eh
000032d0 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC1Ev
00027538 S __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC1Ev.eh
00002cd0 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC2Ev
00027500 S __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC2Ev.eh
         U _fftw_destroy_plan
         U _fftw_execute_dft
         U _fftw_execute_dft_r2c
         U _fftw_import_system_wisdom
         U _fftw_plan_many_dft
         U _fftw_plan_many_dft_r2c
000278e0 S _fftw_planner
         U _fftwf_destroy_plan
         U _fftwf_execute_dft
         U _fftwf_execute_dft_r2c
         U _fftwf_import_system_wisdom
         U _fftwf_plan_many_dft
         U _fftwf_plan_many_dft_r2c
00027880 S _float_fftw_planner
~/Development/octave $


~/Development/octave $ nm liboctave/liboctave.dylib | grep _fftw
00a4afb0 s __GLOBAL__I__ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev
00000000 a __GLOBAL__I__ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev.eh
000469f0 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii
00a61b88 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii.eh
00047c60 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii
00a61ca8 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii.eh
00046750 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKdPSt7complexIdEmmii
00a61b58 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKdPSt7complexIdEmmii.eh
000479d0 T __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKfPSt7complexIfEmmii
00a61c78 S __ZN11octave_fftw3fftEPKfPSt7complexIfEmmii.eh
00046b80 T __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii
00a61bb8 S __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_mmii.eh
00047df0 T __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii
00a61cd8 S __ZN11octave_fftw4ifftEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_mmii.eh
00047590 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
00a61c18 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
00048840 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
00a61d38 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
00046e80 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKdPSt7complexIdEiRK10dim_vector
00a61be8 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKdPSt7complexIdEiRK10dim_vector.eh
000480d0 T __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKfPSt7complexIfEiRK10dim_vector
00a61d08 S __ZN11octave_fftw5fftNdEPKfPSt7complexIfEiRK10dim_vector.eh
00047700 T __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
00a61c48 S __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIdEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
000489b0 T __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector
00a61d68 S __ZN11octave_fftw6ifftNdEPKSt7complexIfEPS1_iRK10dim_vector.eh
00044000 T 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKdPSt7complexIdE
00a619e4 S 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKdPSt7complexIdE.eh
000437e0 T 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIdEPS2_
00a619b4 S 
__ZN19octave_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIdEPS2_.eh
00042e90 T __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE
00a6191c S __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE.eh
00042e80 T __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodEv
00000000 A __ZN19octave_fftw_planner6methodEv.eh
00045550 T __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC1Ev
00a61a7c S __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC1Ev.eh
00044f50 T __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev
00a61a44 S __ZN19octave_fftw_plannerC2Ev.eh
00042fc0 T 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKfPSt7complexIfE
00a61984 S 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEi10dim_vectoriiiPKfPSt7complexIfE.eh
00044740 T 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIfEPS2_
00a61a14 S 
__ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner11create_planEii10dim_vectoriiiPKSt7complexIfEPS2_.eh
00042f20 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE
00a61950 S __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodENS_10FftwMethodE.eh
00042f10 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodEv
00000000 A __ZN25octave_float_fftw_planner6methodEv.eh
00046150 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC1Ev
00a61aec S __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC1Ev.eh
00045b50 T __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC2Ev
00a61ab4 S __ZN25octave_float_fftw_plannerC2Ev.eh
         U _fftw_destroy_plan
         U _fftw_execute_dft
         U _fftw_execute_dft_r2c
         U _fftw_import_system_wisdom
         U _fftw_plan_many_dft
         U _fftw_plan_many_dft_r2c
00c26fa0 S _fftw_planner
         U _fftwf_destroy_plan
         U _fftwf_execute_dft
         U _fftwf_execute_dft_r2c
         U _fftwf_import_system_wisdom
         U _fftwf_plan_many_dft
         U _fftwf_plan_many_dft_r2c
00c26f40 S _float_fftw_planner
~/Development/octave $