Re: [Qemu-ppc] Booting AIX on qemu-system-ppc, kernel not started successfully

[Liang Guo]

On Fri, Feb 24, 2012 at 8:38 PM, Thomas Huth <address@hidden> wrote:
> Am Thu, 23 Feb 2012 19:00:35 +0100
> schrieb Alexander Graf <address@hidden>:
>
> [...]
>> It's not complete though, Thomas has a more complete version in his queue.
>
> FYI: Here's the list of properties that the loader tries to get from
> SLOF/Qemu, but which are not implemented yet:
>
> phandle=0 property='#bytes' not found. (missing nvram node?)
> phandle=1e594d90 property='ibm,lpar-capable' not found.
> phandle=1e594d90 property='ibm,partition-no' not found.
> phandle=1e594d90 property='ibm,platform-hardware-notification' not found.
> phandle=1e594d90 property='system-id' not found.
> phandle=1e595608 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e595608 property='ibm,residual-load' not found.
> phandle=1e595608 property='nvram' not found.
> phandle=1e5959a0 property='ibm,expected#pages' not found.
> phandle=1e5959a0 property='status' not found.
> phandle=1e595b50 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='d-cache-block-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='d-cache-line-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='d-cache-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='d-tlb-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='ibm,dfp' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='ibm,extended-clock-frequency' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='ibm,my-drc-index' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='ibm,pa-features' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='ibm,pa-optimizations' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='ibm,pi-features' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='ibm,spurr' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='i-cache-block-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='i-cache-line-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='i-cache-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='i-tlb-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='l2-cache' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='reservation-granule-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='slb-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='tlbia' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='tlb-sets' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='tlb-size' not found.
> phandle=1e595ca0 property='tlb-split' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='freeze-time-base' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,configure-connector' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,configure-kernel-dump' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,configure-kernel-dump-version' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,display-line-length' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,display-message' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,display-number-of-lines' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,dma-delay-time' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,get-system-parameter' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,lrdr-capacity' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='ibm,max-associativity-domains' not found.
> phandle=1e596230 property='set-indicator' not found.
> phandle=1e5983b0 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e598470 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e598470 property='ibm,aix-package' not found.
> phandle=1e598470 property='ibm,cod-processors' not found.
> phandle=1e598470 property='real-base' not found.
> phandle=1e598640 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e598708 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e598e90 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e59bc48 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e59e290 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e59ecb0 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e5a0e68 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e5a1490 property='device_type' not found.
> phandle=1e5a2d38 property='device_type' not found.
>
I replaced hex phandle with its nodes.
phandle=0 property='#bytes' not found. (missing nvram node?)
phandle=/ property='ibm,lpar-capable' not found.
phandle=/ property='ibm,partition-no' not found.
phandle=/ property='ibm,platform-hardware-notification' not found.
phandle=/ property='system-id' not found.
phandle=/chosen property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/chosen property='ibm,residual-load' not found.
phandle=/chosen property='nvram' not found.
phandle=/address@hidden,0 property='ibm,expected#pages' not found.
phandle=/address@hidden,0 property='status' not found.
phandle=/cpus property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-cache-block-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-cache-line-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-cache-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-tlb-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,dfp' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,extended-clock-frequency' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,my-drc-index' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,pa-features' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,pa-optimizations' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,pi-features' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,spurr' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-cache-block-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-cache-line-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-cache-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-tlb-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='l2-cache' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='reservation-granule-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='slb-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlbia' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlb-sets' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlb-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlb-split' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='freeze-time-base' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,configure-connector' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,configure-kernel-dump' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,configure-kernel-dump-version' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,display-line-length' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,display-message' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,display-number-of-lines' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,dma-delay-time' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,get-system-parameter' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,lrdr-capacity' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,max-associativity-domains' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='set-indicator' not found.
phandle=/aliases property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/options property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/options property='ibm,aix-package' not found.
phandle=/options property='ibm,cod-processors' not found.
phandle=/options property='real-base' not found.
phandle=/packages property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/deblocker property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/disk-label property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/fat-files property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/rom-files property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/ext2-files property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/obp-tftp property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/iso-9660 property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/bulk property='device_type' not found.

The following properties does not exit in a real machine too:
phandle=/packages property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/deblocker property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/disk-label property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/fat-files property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/rom-files property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/ext2-files property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/obp-tftp property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/packages/iso-9660 property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/aliases property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/options property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/cpus property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/chosen property='device_type' not found.
phandle=/address@hidden,0 property='ibm,expected#pages' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlbia' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='l2-cache' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlb-split' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='freeze-time-base' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,configure-kernel-dump' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,configure-kernel-dump-version' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,display-message' not found.
phandle=/options property='ibm,aix-package' not found.
phandle=/options property='ibm,cod-processors' not found.

/bult node even don't exist.

So, following properities may need added to qemu:

phandle=0 property='#bytes' not found. (missing nvram node?)
phandle=/ property='ibm,lpar-capable' not found.
phandle=/ property='ibm,partition-no' not found.
phandle=/ property='ibm,platform-hardware-notification' not found.
phandle=/ property='system-id' not found.
phandle=/chosen property='ibm,residual-load' not found.
phandle=/chosen property='nvram' not found.
phandle=/address@hidden,0 property='status' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-cache-block-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-cache-line-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-cache-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='d-tlb-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,dfp' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,extended-clock-frequency' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,my-drc-index' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,pa-features' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,pa-optimizations' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,pi-features' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='ibm,spurr' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-cache-block-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-cache-line-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-cache-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='i-tlb-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='reservation-granule-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='slb-size' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlb-sets' not found.
phandle=/cpus/address@hidden property='tlb-size' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,configure-connector' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,display-line-length' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,display-number-of-lines' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,dma-delay-time' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,get-system-parameter' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,lrdr-capacity' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='ibm,max-associativity-domains' not found.
phandle=/rtas property='set-indicator' not found.
phandle=/options property='real-base' not found.

Thanks and Regards,
-- 
Liang Guo
http://bluestone.cublog.cn