bug-gnu-utils
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

xgettext: needs a way to set header fields in PO files


From: Santiago Vila
Subject: xgettext: needs a way to set header fields in PO files
Date: Wed, 3 Jan 2007 18:19:16 +0100 (CET)

Hello.

Some time ago (I apologize for taking so long to process this report),
Branden Robinson reported a bug against po-debconf, but it was later
reassigned to gettext. Here is the summary by Denis Barbier:

  I am asked in 251643 to add some functionality to po-debconf so that
  maintainers can easily change header fields in PO files.  This is IMO
  a bad idea, maintainers should *never* modify PO files except for fixing
  bugs and wrong translations (and also change copyright notice yearly);
  maybe you have a different point of view, so I clone and reassign this
  bugreport to gettext.

  In particular for the Project-Id-Version field, it is pretty clear to me
  that this field tells which version translator had worked on last, but
  this is not clearly stated in documentation, so one can also assume that
  all PO files shipped in a tarball have to be set to the current version
  number.

  So please either provide more options to xgettext in order to change
  header fields (and also header comment) or update documentation to state
  that the lack of such options means that only translators have to fill in
  these fields.

Note: I don't know how exactly po-debconf interacts with xgettext, but
I'm sure the CCed people will be able to give details if required.

Thanks.




reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]