[Top][All Lists]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

bug#38358: Subject prefix, true recipient...

From: Narcis Garcia
Subject: bug#38358: Subject prefix, true recipient...
Date: Fri, 29 Nov 2019 13:14:38 +0100

El 28/11/19 a les 19:53, Ian Kelling ha escrit:
> Narcis Garcia via GNUzilla bug reports <address@hidden> writes:
>> El 25/11/19 a les 18:36, Mark H Weaver ha escrit:
>>> Hi Narcis,
>>> Narcis Garcia <address@hidden> wrote:
>>>> El 24/11/19 a les 19:05, Jason Self ha escrit:
>>>>> Mailman does add theList-id header, indicating
>>>>> List-id: GNUzilla bug reports <bug-gnuzilla.gnu.org>
>>>>> Which should make it possible for your mail program to do whatever one
>>>>> wants with such messages.
>>>> I've tried by headers already, and it seems not possible with, for
>>>> example, Mozilla Thunderbird (custom header does not work in a filter 
>>>> rule).
>>> Are you certain of this?  I did a web search found a description of how
>>> to filter on custom headers for mail accounts in Thunderbird.  I tried
>>> it on a friend's instance of Thunderbird.  These are the steps I
>>> followed:
>>> * From the app menu I chose the "Message Filters" menu item, which
>>>   summoned the Message Filters window.
>>> * I clicked the "New..." button, which summoned the Filter Rules window.
>>> * I clicked the popup menu of headers to filter on, and down at the
>>>   bottom of the list I see "Customize...".  Choosing it summons the
>>>   Customize Headers window.  I typed "List-id" in the text box and
>>>   clicked "Add", and then "OK" to dismiss the Customize Headers window.
>>> * "List-id" is now an item within the popup menu of headers to filter
>>>   on.
>>> Does this work for you?
>> No, it doesn't.
>> Even worse: replies like yours (not arriving me through list mailer
>> because of CC recipient) are impossible to filter with any distinction
>> about gnuzilla.
>> List administrators did become crazy to attend DKIM requirements. If
>> DMARC and SPF is used, DKIM doesn't enhance mail at all and list mailers
>> can edit subjects and put footers.
> Not breaking dkim is the only way we can forward your message and comply
> with a strict dmarc policy, well unless you put the gnu lists mail
> server into your spf policy. If you use dmarc without dkim (and dont put
> us in your spf policy), I consider your server to be misconfigured.

Anyway, many list administrators are getting new policies around DKIM,
that will drive mailing lists to death.
The new problem is about usability.

reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]