Re: including gregorian.ly breaks lyrics alignment in melismas

[Xavier Scheuer]

2010/12/27 Janek Warchoł <address@hidden>:
>
> Hi,
>
> Search for "gregorian" in tracker didn't show any results like this,
> so i report:
> including gregorian.ly breaks horizontal spacing when there are lyrics. 
> Example:
>
> \include "gregorian.ly"
> <<
>        \new Voice = foobar { f'( a' g' f') }
>        \new Lyrics \lyricsto foobar \lyricmode { lalah }
> >>
>
> It breaks also with \addlyrics:
>
> \include "gregorian.ly"
> \new Voice = foobar { f'( a' g' f') }
> \addlyrics { lalah }

Hi!

I compiled with 2.13.43 and I did not see an issue here.

The result is exactly the same if we comment  \include "gregorian.ly" ,
so this tends to mean if there is an issue it is not due to this.

I suppose you consider an issue the fact that the syllable is
left-aligned instead of horizontally centered below the first note.
This is due to the slur and is normal behaviour AFAIK.
The slur is creating a melismata and LilyPond tries to horizontally
center the syllable below the whole slurred passage.  But it needs to
stay below the first note also (because that's where the syllable begins),
so it is left-aligned.

Seems "normal" to me, so not an issue here IMHO.

Cheers,
Xavier

-- 
Xavier Scheuer <address@hidden>