bug-lilypond
[Top][All Lists]

Re: Issue 1110 in lilypond: Wrong octave of repetition chord with \relat

 From: lilypond Subject: Re: Issue 1110 in lilypond: Wrong octave of repetition chord with \relative and #{ #} syntax Date: Sun, 16 Oct 2011 07:40:35 +0000

```
```
Comment #15 on issue 1110 by address@hidden: Wrong octave of repetition chord with \relative and #{ #} syntax
```http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=1110

```
Yes, you are naive. q is processed much earlier, in the lexer and parser. But do you really want to have
```\relative c' { <a' c e> q }
equivalent to
\relative c' { <a' c e> <a' c e> }
\relative c' { <a c e> c e q }
equivalent to
\relative c' { <a c e> c e <a c e> }
```
? That means that you _manually_ have to track the progress of pitch octaves, and compensate, and I don't even think that q' or q, are valid commands.
```
```
Basically, you are proposing to restart with the very first implementation of q, and then reopen all related closed bug reports in sequence again. I doubt we'll end up somewhere else.
```

```