Re: Manual beaming over rests and vertical spacing problem

[Federico Bruni]

Il 10/03/2013 20:00, Clément ha scritto:
> > I'm not top posting.
>
> Hello,
>
> Using oneVoice position (or indirectly, partcombineApart) while making a beam go
> over a rest destroys vertical alignment in a staff.

I can see that in the first staff, where you've used manual beams, the 
dynamic signs and the reharsal mark are slightly more distant from the 
other objects comparing with the second staff (where you let the 
automatic beaming doing its job).

I don't know if this qualifies as a bug.
I hope a developer can jump in and reply..

> Here is a small example, with or without manual beaming over the rest.
>
> %%%
>
> \version "2.17.13"
>
> \relative c'' {
>    \voiceOne \dynamicUp f4\fz f8 f f[ r16 f] f8 f |
>    \override DynamicText #'X-offset = #-3 f4\fz f8 f f[ r16 f] f8 f | \mark
> \default
> }
>
> \relative c'' {
>    \voiceOne \dynamicUp f4\fz f8 f f r16 f f8 f |
>    \override DynamicText #'X-offset = #-3 f4\fz f8 f f r16 f f8 f | \mark
> \default
> }
>
> %%%
>
> Overriding outside-staff-priority or Y-offset is uneffective.
> It also affects BarNumber's vertical position.
>
> I encountered this bug while updating a score from an older version of lilypond,
> but I cannot remember which one exactly. I think it was 2.16.

If I compile your example with v2.16, the only difference is the 
reharsal mark at the end of the first staff: it's as close to the staff 
lines as in the second staff.
So something is changed in the development of 2.17
But let's wait for some developer's opinion on this matter.

Thanks for the report
--
Federico