[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: use of 'sendmail -t'
Re: use of 'sendmail -t'
Tue, 06 May 2003 19:30:41 +0200
Gnus/5.1002 (Gnus v5.10.2) Emacs/21.3.50 (gnu/linux)
"Greg A. Woods" <address@hidden> writes:
> [ On Tuesday, May 6, 2003 at 06:13:50 (-0400), Richard Stallman wrote: ]
>> Subject: Re: use of 'sendmail -t'
>> I believe fencepost is running exim. Can you tell me how to verify
>> that it is really exim?
> I wasn't able to get Exim to build with just a very quick try in
> NetBSD's pkgsrc, however I was able to find the following paragraph in
> Exim's manual (exim-4.10/doc/spec.txt):
> If there are any "Resent-" headers in the message, an error is
> generated, and Exim gives up. RFC 2822 talks about different sets of
> "Resent-" headers (when a message is resent several times), and it is
> not at all clear how -t should operate in this situation. Experiments
> with Sendmail have shown that it amalgamates multiple sets of "Resent-"
> headers when -t is used. This does not seem to be in the spirit of RFC
> This does indeed suggest that Exim is one of the few, and maybe only,
> sendmail-compatible mailer which does not support "Resent-*" destination
> headers in combination with use of 'sendmail -t'.
I believe this is a bug in Exim. I think it is pretty clear from RFC
2822 that the first Resent-* block is the valid one, if any Resent-*
blocks exist at all. It is unfortunate that a MUST statement wasn't
used when saying that the fields are prepended to the message. This
was undefined in RFC 822 though.
| 3.6.6. Resent fields
| Resent fields SHOULD be added to any message that is reintroduced by
| a user into the transport system. A separate set of resent fields
| SHOULD be added each time this is done. All of the resent fields
| corresponding to a particular resending of the message SHOULD be
| together. Each new set of resent fields is prepended to the message;
| that is, the most recent set of resent fields appear earlier in the
| message. No other fields in the message are changed when resent
| fields are added.
> In the mean time I will submit a proposal to Philip Hazel suggesting
> that he re-evaluate his position on the support of "Resent-*" headers
> when '-t' is used and hopefully Exim will soon become compatible with
> Sendmail, Smail, Postfix, and other sendmail-compatible mailers.
Ah, we agree. Good.
Don't forget to ask for the documentation to be updated. "-t"
currently doesn't mention Resent-* at all, in all manuals I looked in.