tabulated-list-mode needs incremental search option

[Jean Louis]

* Chong Yidong <cyd@stupidchicken.com> [2020-11-10 10:25]:
> Hi Jean Louis,
> 
> > But now when you gave me references on how to filter the view then I
> > can make function for my particular case myself to enter one or more
> > words to filter by words. That is workaround, not real solution.
> > ...
> > In my opinion the above is enough for me. You said how / k filtering
> > is implemented, even I used it but I forgot it. You reminded me, so
> > now I can filter in similar way myself.
> >
> > If it happens that you decide to improve it, I have idea how you could
> > do it: simply concatenating all tabulated items with space between and
> > then using matching words on that list.
> 
> Glad the interim solution can be done.
> 
> I think the incremental typing functionality is best implemented as its
> own minor mode.  It should not be tied to tabulated-list-mode.
> 
> This could be modelled after Emacs' completion functions.  In
> completion, you start typing and Emacs draws in information from the
> buffer to try and complete what you have in the minibuffer.  In the new
> incremental processing mode, you start typing and Emacs alters the
> buffer to reflect what's in the minibuffer.  Similar to completion, it
> would not be mode-specific, but different modes would be able to
> customize the effects in a way that makes sense for that mode.
> 
> Could you file a feature request in the Emacs bug tracker, or send an
> email to emacs-devel to open a discussion?  It's possible there's
> already related functionality that I'm not current aware of, e.g. in an
> external package.

I will Cc: this email to emacs-devel.

In general I am advising that every application with choices offers
among others the narrowing incremental search.

Be it by invoking a key binding first or directly by simply
typing. Because there are various key bindings in almost every mode it
is better to start narrowing incremental seach when user press special
key like / or something.

To come out of narrowed list one could press other key binding and see
the original list.

In my program I am using (setq tabulated-list-entries entries) and it
is common in tabulated-list-mode.

In my program I am using (setq tabulated-list-entries entries) and it
is common in tabulated-list-mode.

So I guess it could be implemented as you said in a derived mode
invoked by programmer or program where:

- user press some key to start a real-time narrowing incremental
  search

- program remembers the original `tabulated-list-entries' as
  ORIGINAL-DATA

- program can concatenate parts of each entry into strings (or maybe
  use other method) during the incremental narrowing search

- user starts typing and lines shown in tabulated-list-mode get
  narrowed to selected lines

- program obtains the ID numbers and displays only those ID numbers by
  using (setq tabulated-list-entries NARROWED-DATA) and redisplays

- use could press ENTER and narrowing incremental search stops at that
  point, user is facing new tabulated list and can handle it in usual
  manner.

- user may press a key to go back to go to original
  `tabulated-list-entries' and program does (setq
  tabulated-list-entries ORIGINAL-DATA) and re-displays

Jean