|
From: | kautz |
Subject: | [gnugo-devel] evaluation and timing / was Re: gnugo-devel Digest, Vol 42, Issue 24 |
Date: | Thu, 01 Jun 2006 20:00:05 +0200 |
User-agent: | Thunderbird 1.5.0.2 (Windows/20060308) |
John Tromp schrieb:
I made a quick-and-diry timing test generating a black move at this position with levels 10 to 16 - see attachment. I will try on with level 15 and different random seeds to see if there are significant timing changes.> It next twice defeated 9x9 winner > CrazyStone but only after allowing gnugo to void a game in which > gnugo at lvl 15 took seemingly forever on a single move. Yeah, high levels tend to be unpredictable. Do you still have the position available?It's the position at the end of gnu-crazy.sgf. I suspect GnuGo had used more than half an hour thinking time when I killed it.
Some dumb questions to the developers / good go players:- Is this a reasonable approach in helping track this bug down? (loadsgf, then genmove) Or is it necessary to replay every move to update the cache states?
- What would be some good moves for black in this position?- What are the main problems in this game state that tend to slow down GNU Go?
- Is this a typical timing-problematic position?I'd envision a "incremental evaluation" for GNU Go that could be interrupted almost any time giving a move reflecting best knowledge so far. But I don't know how that could be implemented or if GNU Go's eval could at least be tweaked into this direction ...
I'd like some comments on this ... happy GO - ing aquarius
make worms: 2.47 sec owl reading: 8.71 sec semeai module: 2.95 sec examine position: 14.99 sec find_more_attack_and_defense_moves: 1.18 sec find_more_owl_attack_and_defense_moves: 1.40 sec Strategic defense at S10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at T10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D5 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on E1 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on E1 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on E1 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at L2 induced for J4 due to owl attack on K2 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at G1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on E1 B8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) C7: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D5: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D5: 13.87 - J4 strategic attack/defend D5: 2.28 - C5 strategic attack/defend D8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D9: 2.28 - C5 strategic attack/defend E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of E1 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 0.0 - 'attack either' is redundant at F5 (direct att./def. as well) E2: 2.28 - C5 strategic attack/defend E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 13.87 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 2.28 - C5 strategic attack/defend E4: 2.60 - D4 strategic attack/defend E4: 12.24 - F5 strategic attack/defend E4: 27.37 - F5 cut/connect strategic value E4: 3.52 - D4 cut/connect strategic value E8: 2.28 - C5 strategic attack/defend G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F1 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 13.87 - J4 strategic attack/defend G1: 2.28 - C5 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.21 - J5 cut/connect strategic value J16: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) J18: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) K5: 0.12 - J5 cut/connect strategic value K5: 0.26 - R6 cut/connect strategic value L2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of K2 (owl attack/defense as well) L2: 13.87 - J4 strategic attack/defend L2: 12.68 - K2 cut/connect strategic value L13: 0.72 - P15 cut/connect strategic value O19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) O19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) P19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) P19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) Q19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) Q19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) S10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) T2: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T5: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) value_moves: 11.17 sec Top moves: 1. E4 54.55 2. G1 53.55 3. D5 48.56 4. E2 23.43 5. L2 22.16 6. H6 21.67 7. N8 16.99 8. D2 16.69 9. K14 15.64 10. N7 15.04 review move reasons: 14.10 sec TIME to generate move at E4: 27.55 sec make worms: 4.51 sec owl reading: 10.33 sec semeai module: 14.65 sec examine position: 30.93 sec generate move reasons: 1.87 sec combinations: 5.79 sec find_more_owl_attack_and_defense_moves: 6.28 sec Strategic defense at S10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at T10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 B8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) C7: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D5: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 2.14 - D4 strategic attack/defend E4: 11.85 - F5 strategic attack/defend E4: 25.81 - F5 cut/connect strategic value E4: 2.84 - D4 cut/connect strategic value G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F1 (owl attack/defense as well) J16: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) J18: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) L2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of K2 (owl attack/defense as well) L2: 0.0 - (threat to) win semeai involving K2 (owl move as well) L2: 0.0 - (threat to) win semeai involving J4 (owl move as well) L2: 0.0 - (threat to) win semeai involving K2 (tactical move as well) L2: 15.89 - J4 attacked/defended L13: 0.72 - P15 cut/connect strategic value O19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) O19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) P19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) P19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) Q19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) Q19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) S10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) T2: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T5: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) value_moves: 9.72 sec Top moves: 1. E4 54.97 2. D5 50.36 3. G1 50.02 4. L2 35.33 5. N8 16.97 6. K14 15.63 7. N7 15.01 8. O9 14.71 9. J13 14.42 10. S10 14.05 review move reasons: 19.17 sec TIME to generate move at E4: 53.64 sec make worms: 8.97 sec owl reading: 19.17 sec semeai module: 9.97 sec examine position: 40.33 sec combinations: 1.59 sec find_more_attack_and_defense_moves: 4.91 sec find_more_owl_attack_and_defense_moves: 3.91 sec Strategic defense at S10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at T10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at H6 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at H6 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at H6 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D5 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at L2 induced for J4 due to owl attack on K2 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at G1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 B8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) C7: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D5: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D5: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend D8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 2.14 - D4 strategic attack/defend E4: 11.35 - F5 strategic attack/defend E4: 23.94 - F5 cut/connect strategic value E4: 2.84 - D4 cut/connect strategic value G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F1 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) H6: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.21 - J5 cut/connect strategic value J16: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) J18: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) K5: 0.12 - J5 cut/connect strategic value K5: 0.26 - R6 cut/connect strategic value L2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of K2 (owl attack/defense as well) L2: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend L2: 12.44 - K2 cut/connect strategic value L13: 0.72 - P15 cut/connect strategic value O19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) O19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) P19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) P19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) Q19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) Q19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) S10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) T2: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T5: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) value_moves: 19.99 sec Top moves: 1. H6 54.38 2. E4 39.99 3. G1 39.59 4. D5 34.59 5. L2 21.94 6. N8 16.97 7. K14 15.58 8. E2 15.14 9. N7 15.03 10. O9 14.75 review move reasons: 30.77 sec TIME to generate move at H6: 64.54 sec make worms: 22.03 sec owl reading: 29.43 sec semeai module: 19.89 sec examine position: 75.08 sec shapes: 2.10 sec combinations: 2.25 sec find_more_attack_and_defense_moves: 10.97 sec find_more_owl_attack_and_defense_moves: 9.58 sec Strategic defense at S10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at T10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at H6 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at H6 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at H6 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at L2 induced for J4 due to owl attack on K2 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at G1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 B8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) C7: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D5: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E4: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 2.14 - D4 strategic attack/defend E4: 11.35 - F5 strategic attack/defend E4: 23.94 - F5 cut/connect strategic value E4: 2.84 - D4 cut/connect strategic value G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F1 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) H6: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.21 - J5 cut/connect strategic value J16: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) J18: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) K5: 0.21 - J5 cut/connect strategic value K5: 3.04 - R6 cut/connect strategic value L2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of K2 (owl attack/defense as well) L2: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend L2: 12.44 - K2 cut/connect strategic value L13: 0.72 - P15 cut/connect strategic value O19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) O19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) P19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) P19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) Q19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) Q19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) S10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) T2: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T5: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) value_moves: 33.75 sec Top moves: 1. H6 54.38 2. G1 39.59 3. E4 37.65 4. K5 22.07 5. L2 21.94 6. N8 16.98 7. K14 15.59 8. E2 15.15 9. N7 15.03 10. O9 14.74 review move reasons: 59.19 sec TIME to generate move at H6: 116.59 sec make worms: 52.77 sec owl reading: 62.63 sec semeai module: 48.84 sec examine position: 171.50 sec shapes: 5.94 sec combinations: 22.28 sec find_more_attack_and_defense_moves: 34.17 sec find_more_owl_attack_and_defense_moves: 14.41 sec Strategic defense at S10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at T10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E3 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E3 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E3 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at L2 induced for J4 due to owl attack on K2 Strategic defense at D1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at G1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 B8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) C7: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) D1: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) D1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend D5: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E3: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E3: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E3: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E3: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E4: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 2.14 - D4 strategic attack/defend E4: 11.35 - F5 strategic attack/defend E4: 23.94 - F5 cut/connect strategic value E4: 2.84 - D4 cut/connect strategic value G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F1 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.21 - J5 cut/connect strategic value J16: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) J18: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) K5: 0.12 - J5 cut/connect strategic value K5: 0.26 - R6 cut/connect strategic value L2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of K2 (owl attack/defense as well) L2: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend L2: 12.44 - K2 cut/connect strategic value L13: 0.72 - P15 cut/connect strategic value O19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) O19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) P19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) P19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) Q19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) Q19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) S10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) T2: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T5: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) value_moves: 84.14 sec Top moves: 1. G1 39.59 2. E4 37.66 3. D1 34.25 4. E3 34.04 5. L2 21.95 6. H6 21.66 7. N8 16.97 8. K14 15.58 9. E2 15.14 10. N7 15.03 review move reasons: 133.16 sec TIME to generate move at G1: 280.11 sec make worms: 150.93 sec owl reading: 177.77 sec semeai module: 202.61 sec examine position: 549.19 sec shapes: 18.07 sec combinations: 63.79 sec find_more_attack_and_defense_moves: 98.22 sec find_more_owl_attack_and_defense_moves: 35.54 sec Strategic defense at S10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at T10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D5 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E3 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E3 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E3 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at L2 induced for J4 due to owl attack on K2 Strategic defense at D1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at G1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 B8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) C7: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) D1: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) D1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend D5: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D5: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend D8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E3: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E3: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E3: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E3: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E4: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 2.14 - D4 strategic attack/defend E4: 11.35 - F5 strategic attack/defend E4: 23.94 - F5 cut/connect strategic value E4: 2.84 - D4 cut/connect strategic value G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F1 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.21 - J5 cut/connect strategic value J16: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) J18: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) K5: 0.12 - J5 cut/connect strategic value K5: 0.26 - R6 cut/connect strategic value L2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of K2 (owl attack/defense as well) L2: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend L2: 12.44 - K2 cut/connect strategic value L13: 0.72 - P15 cut/connect strategic value O19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) O19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) P19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) P19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) Q19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) Q19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) S10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) T2: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T5: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) value_moves: 256.07 sec Top moves: 1. G1 39.59 2. E4 37.66 3. D5 34.59 4. D1 34.25 5. E3 34.03 6. L2 21.95 7. H6 21.66 8. N8 16.97 9. K14 15.59 10. E2 15.14 review move reasons: 390.47 sec TIME to generate move at G1: 870.59 sec make worms: 626.96 sec owl reading: 389.46 sec semeai module: 601.77 sec examine position: 1664.93 sec shapes: 107.00 sec combinations: 164.15 sec find_more_attack_and_defense_moves: 878.55 sec find_more_owl_attack_and_defense_moves: 191.51 sec Strategic defense at S10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at T10 induced for Q8 due to owl attack on S9 Strategic defense at H6 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at H6 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at H6 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at D5 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D5 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E4 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E3 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E3 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at E3 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at E2 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at L2 induced for J4 due to owl attack on K2 Strategic defense at D1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at D1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on D4 Strategic defense at G1 induced for C5 due to owl attack on F5 Strategic defense at G1 induced for J4 due to owl attack on F5 B8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) C7: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) D1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) D1: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) D1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend D5: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) D5: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend D8: 1.25 (secondary) - attack on C6 (defenseless) E2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E2: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E3: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E3: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E3: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E3: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) E4: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) E4: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend E4: 2.14 - D4 strategic attack/defend E4: 11.35 - F5 strategic attack/defend E4: 23.94 - F5 cut/connect strategic value E4: 2.84 - D4 cut/connect strategic value F7: 0.0 - 'attack either' is redundant at G6 (direct att./def. as well) F7: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of D4 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F1 (owl attack/defense as well) G1: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of F5 (owl attack/defense as well) H6: 1.30 (secondary) - attack on E1 (dead) H6: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend H6: 0.21 - J5 cut/connect strategic value J16: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) J18: 1.42 (secondary) - attack on J17 (defenseless) K5: 0.12 - J5 cut/connect strategic value K5: 0.26 - R6 cut/connect strategic value L2: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of K2 (owl attack/defense as well) L2: 13.66 - J4 strategic attack/defend L2: 12.44 - K2 cut/connect strategic value L13: 0.72 - P15 cut/connect strategic value O19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) O19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) P19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) P19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) Q19: 10.25 (secondary) - attack on O18 (defenseless) Q19: 0.50 (secondary) - attack on N19 (dead) S10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) T2: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T5: 4.25 (secondary) - attack on S4 (defenseless) T10: 0.0 - (threat of) attack/defense of S9 (owl attack/defense as well) value_moves: 1050.97 sec Top moves: 1. H6 54.43 2. G1 39.59 3. E4 37.66 4. D5 34.59 5. D1 34.25 6. E3 34.04 7. L2 21.95 8. F7 21.54 9. N8 16.97 10. K14 15.59 review move reasons: 2248.43 sec TIME to generate move at H6: 3557.56 sec
level | random_seed | top_move | move_value | total_time | make_worms | owl_reading | semeai_module | examine_position | gen_move_reasons | shapes | combinations | find_more_att_def | find_more_owl_att_def | value_moves | review_reasons |
10 | 0 | E4 | 54.55 | 27,55 | 2,47 | 8,71 | 2,95 | 14,99 | / | / | / | 1,18 | 1,4 | 11,17 | 14,1 |
11 | 2022858599 | E4 | 54.97 | 53,64 | 4,51 | 10,33 | 14,65 | 30,93 | 1,87 | / | 5,79 | / | 6,28 | 9,72 | 19,17 |
12 | 2047190901 | H6 | 54.38 | 64,54 | 8,97 | 19,17 | 9,97 | 40,33 | / | / | 1,59 | 4,91 | 3,91 | 19,99 | 30,77 |
13 | 1126287790 | H6 | 54.38 | 116,59 | 22,03 | 29,43 | 19,89 | 75,08 | / | 2,1 | 2,25 | 10,97 | 9,58 | 33,75 | 59,19 |
14 | 2111162242 | G1 | 39.59 | 280,11 | 52,77 | 62,63 | 48,84 | 171,5 | / | 5,94 | 22,28 | 34,17 | 14,41 | 84,14 | 133,16 |
15 | 1698431592 | G1 | 39.59 | 870,59 | 150,93 | 177,77 | 202,61 | 549,19 | / | 18,07 | 63,79 | 98,22 | 35,54 | 256,07 | 390,47 |
16 | 2002442235 | H6 | 54.43 | 3557,56 | 626,96 | 389,46 | 601,77 | 1664,93 | / | 107 | 164,15 | 878,55 | 191,51 | 1050,97 | 2248,43 |
TEST RESULTS: See timing-test.html for table of results. See log.txt for complete output including top 10 moves and move reasons. TESTING METHOD: gnugo -r 0 --mode gtp --chinese-rules --play-out-aftermath --never-resign -M 128 --showtime --debug 0x400800 --gtp-input test.gtp >random_seeds.txt 2> log.txt TEST.GTP CONTENTS: loadsgf crazy-gnu-forever.sgf level 10 get_random_seed genmove black boardsize 19 clear_board clear_cache loadsgf crazy-gnu-forever.sgf level 11 get_random_seed genmove black boardsize 19 clear_board clear_cache loadsgf crazy-gnu-forever.sgf level 12 get_random_seed genmove black ... and so on until level 16 ...
[Prev in Thread] | Current Thread | [Next in Thread] |