[bug#62642] [PATCH] services: certbot: Fix nginx crash when certbot is used without domains

[Bruno Victal]

On 2023-04-03 19:06, Saku Laesvuori wrote:
> Hi,
> 
>> Is there a use-case for certbot without any certificate configurations 
>> provided?
> 
> I was writing a service that extends certbot if a configuration option
> for it is set to #t. To me it seems that it is currently impossible to
> view the configuration in the service type definition, so I worked
> around it by extending certbot-service-type with an empty list if the
> option is set to #f.

Right, that's a valid use case.

> 
>> IMO it looks to me that the 'certificates' field shouldn't have a default 
>> value
>> configured instead?
> 
> Wouldn't that mean that users who use certbot only via services that
> extend it would have to configure 'certificates' to () manually and have
> their nginx configuration crash if they remove the extending services
> and forget to remove the certbot service?

You're correct, having the default value set is not a problem here.

IMO, certbot should be extending the nginx service only when the 'challenge' 
field
is #f (ideally this should be made into a “enumerated” type, where the values 
range from
'http-01, 'dns-01, 'custom (as an escape hatch), ...)

Perhaps you could partition 'certificates' by whether 'challenge' is #f or not 
and use the
results to craft the nginx extension value instead?


Cheers,
Bruno