[Top][All Lists]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Help-librejs] You can now register as a DMCA agent without using no

From: Joe Clayton
Subject: Re: [Help-librejs] You can now register as a DMCA agent without using nonfree JavaScript
Date: Tue, 14 Nov 2017 20:39:29 -0500

I am sorry guys, but you are fighting a losing battle here. 

No web site admin/maintainer is going to dig through hundreds (in our case, thousands) of web pages to figure out if we have 'non-free' modules, replace those _javascript_ modules/code with 'free' versions, or more to the point, release our own _javascript_ - which support commercial 'web applications' - as free. Only an idiot is going to spend thousands of dollars and months of time developing a commercial web app - and I don't know of any that don't include _javascript_ - and then release it as free code. 

Also, I - like many -  have no intention being forced to use Firefox - when we prefer Chrome - only to enforce all of that 'only free' _javascript_. Frankly, as a user, if I am paying to use a commercial web app, and 'LibreJS' or anything else starts blocking code because it is 'non-free' - I would immediately rip it out.

I hope our donations to FSF are NOT focused on this effort to get every web site to agree to only use 'free' _javascript_, because it is just not going to fly. A better approach is guidelines/rules/laws that limit what 'non-free' _javascript_ is allowed to do, such as not collect/mine information.

Joe Clayton
Creative Software

On Tue, Nov 14, 2017 at 12:54 AM, Donald Robertson, III, FSF <address@hidden> wrote:
Free Software Foundation

Read online:

Dear Joe Clayton,

With the deadline for registering as a DMCA agent looming at the end of the year, these two add-ons allow you to register without the use of nonfree _javascript_.

Users shouldn't be forced to use nonfree software when interacting with their own government. Every user has the right to control their own computing, and the government shouldn't force you to download and install proprietary software just to take advantage of its services. But when it comes to registering as an agent under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act (DMCA) in the United States, that's exactly what the government expects you to do.

Users are likely familiar with the DMCA's more draconian aspects, namely the creation of legal penalties for circumventing Digital Restrictions Management. The Free Software Foundation's Defective by Design campaign is fighting to end that nightmare and repeal that part of the law. But like many laws, it's crammed full of a wide variety of provisions, the anti-circumvention rules being only one of them.

Another piece of the law creates what are known as the safe harbor provisions. These rules set out some steps that maintainers of Web sites can take to avoid liability when a user of their site uploads potentially infringing copyrighted materials. The main provision here is that if a copyright holder finds their work on your site without their permission, they can submit a take down notice to an agent registered for your site. This agent can then remove the work, thus avoiding liability for the potentially infringing distribution. Without this safe harbor, the site maintainer could potentially be sued.

While this safe harbor rule can lead to abuse, with improper take downs, it also allows maintainers of Web sites to permit their users to share works. If the rule wasn't in place, it would be too dangerous to accept such uploads without reviewing each work -- something most Web sites can't afford to do. The Free Software Foundation takes advantage of the safe harbor provisions to ensure that we can continue to share software created and uploaded by free software developers, or to share information like that found in the Free Software Directory, or to help people organize locally via

As mentioned before, though, taking advantage of the safe harbor provisions requires having an agent to accept the notices. This is where the problem arises. The U.S. Copyright Office is now requiring Web site maintainers to re-register using by December 31st of 2017. This site, like many others that the Copyright Office requires use of, is lousy with nonfree _javascript_. Unlike the server software you may interact with when visiting any Web site, _javascript_ is actually downloaded and run on your machine. Like any proprietary software, it does not serve the user, and cannot be trusted. Users must avoid nonfree _javascript_ just as they would avoid any piece of proprietary software. But if they want to continue to enjoy safe harbor provisions, they must allow this intrusion onto their computer.

The Free Software Foundation reached out to the Copyright Office with these issues, and we still hope to work out a solution with them for the long term. But with the deadline coming up, we had to fix it ourselves. We collaborated with a volunteer to develop a workaround that allows you to register using only free software. The fix requires installing two freely licensed add-ons, Register DMCA claim contacts w/o bad _javascript_ and Automatically reveal hidden HTML elements. These add-ons, when used with GNU LibreJS, allow anyone who needs to register as a DMCA agent to do so without loading the harmful nonfree _javascript_.

There are still a few quirks that are being hammered out. Currently you have to add alternate names by uploading a document rather than filling in a text field. The only document type that they will accept is Excel, a proprietary format, but users can create documents in that format using LibreOffice. It's not a perfect solution, but it does enable users to actually complete the entire registration process using only free software. We will also be talking with the Copyright Office about supporting better formats. That is one of the beautiful things about free software: when people see a problem and have control over their own tools, they have the power to come together and make things right.

Users have a right to control their own computing. Governments everywhere should ensure that participating in any program they provide does not require the use of nonfree software. But where governments are slow to react, we all have to work together to route around the threat of proprietary software. Here's what you can do to help:

  • Spread the word to any Web site maintainers you know that they can register using free software.
  • Use the add-ons to register for your own sites, and let us know you did by emailing us at address@hidden.
  • Help improve GNU LibreJS.
  • Support the work of the Free Software Foundation by donating or becoming a member.

Donald Robertson, III
Licensing and Compliance Manager

Follow us on GNU social | Subscribe to our blogs via RSS | Join us as an associate member

Sent from the Free Software Foundation,

51 Franklin St, Fifth Floor
Boston, Massachusetts 02110-1335

Unsubscribe from this mailing list.

Stop all email from the Free Software Foundation, including Defective by Design, and the Free Software Supporter newsletter.

reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]