Re: [Lilypond-auto] Issue 2683 in lilypond: Beamlets with incorrect orientation and uneven spacing in beamlet-test.ly

[lilypond]

Comment #1 on issue 2683 by address@hidden: Beamlets with incorrect  
orientation and uneven spacing in beamlet-test.ly
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2683

The test beamlet-test.ly changed with the fix to issue 2386, and apparently  
the change is smaller than the threshold in the regression tester.

The fix to issue 2386 seems to intentionally include tuplets when setting  
the priority to beam respecting the (time-signature) beat.  Maybe we want  
to include only tuplets divisible by 2 ?

I would have thought, contrary to Colin and Arnold, that the way 2.15.41  
and 2.14.2 handle this is correct.  If the beam were not forced across the  
5-tuplets, these "simply wrong" beamlet directions would be the only  
possible directions.

If there is doubt about how people will really want them to be printed in  
real music, I suggest removing the 5-tuplet cases from the test suite.

Attachments:
        A.png  9.2 KB
        a.ly  259 bytes