Re: The hel-arabic.ly file story...

[Luca Fascione]

Hassan,
it would help us enormously if you could share with us the reasoning behind
these choices.
For example, you stated "All key signatures for maqams go in hel-arabic.ly":
could you explain to us
why this is the better place for them, compared to arabic.ly?
This will provide some intuition to all involved as to how to make similar
choices in the future, for example.

Many thanks
Luca

On Fri, Jan 13, 2023 at 9:07 AM <hassan.elfatihi@free.fr> wrote:

> Hello
> Answers to questions
> Question : while hel-arabic.ly has this line that
> includes arabic.ly , what are they getting out of this? Some more
> key signatures and keyAlterationOrder?
>
> answer: normally hel-arabic.ly doesn't need arabic.ly (if not modified,
> as recently proposed)
>
> Question: Should all key signatures for the various maqams simply go only
> into
> arabic.ly ?
> Answer : All key signatures for the various maqams simply go only into
> hel-arabic.ly
> (if not modified, as recently proposed)
> If you want examples I can provide them.
> This is why I did not want to link hel-arabic.ly to arabic.ly
> Best regard
>
>

-- 
Luca Fascione