Re: where's the slur? (4 year old question)

[-Eluze]

Villum Sejersen wrote:
> 
>>  it seems i can't get VoiceB (the c's) to have a tie going up (with
>> version 2.15.5)!
> 
> Neither can I, at least not without any tweaks or overrides. :)
> 
i tried many tweaks - without success :-(


> 
>>  this works in one voice (without to many tweaks)!
>>  {
>>    \tieDown
>>    \slurUp
>>    <e' c' -\tweak #'direction #1 ~ a  ~>>2(<d' c' a>>  )
>>  }
> 
>  From a score-readability point-of-view Keith O'Hara's solution no.1 is
> clearly the best I have seen so far.
> 
yes, and it's interesting to watch the positioning and attachment varying
with implicit or explicit settings (_ or ^) 

the main question however is if it is a chord or a polyphonic construction -
which is not up to me/us to decide - both of them lead to different
positions of the notes in the second (d' c').

Eluze
-- 
View this message in context: 
http://old.nabble.com/where%27s-the-slur--%284-year-old-question%29-tp32122228p32124857.html
Sent from the Gnu - Lilypond - User mailing list archive at Nabble.com.