lilypond-user
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Possibly silly question but…


From: David Rogers
Subject: Re: Possibly silly question but…
Date: Sat, 28 Nov 2020 11:45:56 -0800
User-agent: Gnus/5.13 (Gnus v5.13) Emacs/27.1 (gnu/linux)

That’s quite an honour - thanks! Though for myself I’d have to rank many other posts higher, mainly ones in which someone creates a brilliant/elegant solution to a problem.

Leaving a blank space in what’s normally the clef area tends to make it look as if something is missing; the three letters do fill the gap. And (I hadn’t thought of this part) I suspect that the frequent use of all-caps italic is intended to make the thing look more like a “proper clef” - the treble and bass clefs are curly and usually have contrasting stroke width - and if that’s the reasoning, then some kind of “copperplate” style would be a better fit than the edged-pen style I’ve sometimes seen.

BUT - “Proper clefs” are functional, and T A B isn’t. Since a guitar-tab staff represents strings, I’d suggest that a real proper guitar tab clef could be something that shows what tuning is being used. But maybe that’s problematic for other reasons, and I can’t even play guitar, so I’ll be quiet now.

David R


Andrew Bernard <andrew.bernard@gmail.com> writes:

Hello David,

I feel compelled to say this is the best post I have ever seen on this list, on any topic! Marvellous.

As an aside, I find the TAB symbol just particularly dreadful. But I often wonder why tablature even needs it - surely it is obvious that what follows is tab, and it does not indicate relative pitch. Well, I am not a guitarist.


Andrew


On 28/11/2020 1:27 pm, David Rogers wrote:

If those letters were human, they’d each be wearing a fancy red dress. And also a fancy blue dress at the same time, with a big metallic-gold sash. And they’d have their hair in ringlets, and pinned in their hair they’d each have two peonies in full bloom. And every time you played the guitar, they would sing, in Spanish and Ukrainian and Igbo, each one singing all three languages at once, with different lyrics. And it would be strangely glorious, and for this you would be the envy of all your friends. Until you discovered that along with the dresses and the hair and the flowers, they’re vain and egotistical, constantly preening and showing off and trying to outdo each other, and once they start singing they won’t shut up.

So it’s probably a good thing they’re just letters. :)




reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]