[Top][All Lists]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Octsympy question

From: Andrés Prieto
Subject: Re: Octsympy question
Date: Thu, 27 Nov 2014 15:14:16 +0100
User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:24.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/24.2.0

Hi Colin,

1. It should be great to be involved in the implementation of initial or boundary conditions for ODEs or other issues related to octsympy. Your quick-and-dirty fix for dsolve looks feasible. 2-3. Since octsympy is beta, we keep in mind to file any kind of issue related with its use. 4. To involve students in the development at any level (as beta testers or beginner developers) should be also great but I'm afraid that such offer will have a very reduced audience.


On 25/11/14 10:35, Andrés Prieto wrote:
My colleagues and me are planning to use the Octave package
"octsympy" to teach some lab computer sessions devoted to Calculus
(Differentiation, Ordinary Differential Equations, etc) in the next

Some further thoughts.  I'd be thrilled to see it used in this way so
please keep in touch.

1.  Be careful of "dsolve": it does not support initial conditions
(which is probably bad for an ODEs course!)


Would you like to help with this?  We can do it together.  I think a
quick-and-dirty fix involving "solve" to determine the constants of
integration is possible, at least for simpler things like linear
second-order constant coefficient BVPs.  Conditions on derivatives
($y'(0) = 1$) might be harder.  (Longer term, this should/will be fixed
in SymPy.)

2.  Please point out to your students that this is beta.  Ideally they
should file issues they encounter.

3.  Please file issues that *you* encounter, even if they are just notes
of things that do not work yet, or otherwise seem trivial.

4.  Would you have scope to consider incorporating an optional exercise
(for strong students) to encourage contribution?  A tractable thing
would be have them construct a simple test case (say a particular
derivative/integral/ODE and its solution).

Filing a bug with a bit of code that should work but does not is nice

Or they could go further and submit a "pull request" of their test to
OctSymPy on github.  Another student could review the code and give it a
"+1" or suggest revisions.  Then you or I consider it and merge.  They
get some bonus points, learn Git, and the thrill of working on
community-developed software.  Great for their CV.

In general there are lots of "low hanging fruit" here: I've started
labeling "easy to fix" bugs that would be appropriate for an interested
student to hack on.


reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]