Re: virtiofsd: Where should it live?

[Markus Armbruster]

Thomas Huth <address@hidden> writes:

> On 02/12/2019 13.56, Markus Armbruster wrote:
>> Peter Maydell <address@hidden> writes:
>> 
>>> On Tue, 26 Nov 2019 at 12:15, Dr. David Alan Gilbert
>>> <address@hidden> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> * Daniel P. Berrangé (address@hidden) wrote:
>>>>> My main objection to 'contrib/' is actually the perceived notions
>>>>> about what the contrib directory is for. When I see 'contrib/'
>>>>> code in either QEMU, or other open source projects, my general
>>>>> impression is that this is largely unsupported code which is just
>>>>> there as it might be interesting to someone, and doesn't typically
>>>>> get much ongoing dev attention.
>>>
>>>>> virtiofsd is definitely different as it is intended to be a
>>>>> fully production quality supported tool with active dev into
>>>>> the future IIUC.
>>>>>
>>>>> IOW, if we did decide we want it in QEMU, then instead of
>>>>> '$GIT/contrib/virtiofsd', I'd prefer to see '$GIT/virtiofsd'.
>>>>
>>>> I'm not sure it deserves a new top level for such a specific tool.
>>>
>>> Maybe, but I think I agree with Daniel that 'contrib/' is
>>> probably not the right place for it if it's something that
>>> we care about supporting. 'contrib' to me is "bucket of stuff
>>> that we didn't really feel strongly we wanted to reject but
>>> which is probably random special-cases or other obscure
>>> stuff, don't bother looking in here and don't assume it's
>>> going to work either".
>> 
>> Agree.
>> 
>> We have source for several separate programs in the root directory
>> already: qemu-bridge-helper, qemu-edid, qemu-img, qemu-io, qemu-nbd,
>> qemu-keymap, qemu-seccomp, qemu-ga.  Just a .c file when that suffixes,
>> else a subdirectory, except for qemu-io, which is two .c files in the
>> root, plus include/qemu-io.h.  Putting virtiofsd/ there follows
>> qemu-ga's precedence.
>
> IMHO the root directory is still way too overcrowded. Maybe we should
> simply introduce a "tools" subdirectory?

Maybe.  In general, I prefer my source trees shallow.

We've sucked at keeping new files out of the root that don't belong
there.  Mending our ways going forward is just one half of the fix.  The
other half is cleaning up the mess we made.

The manual should be somewhere below docs/.

Several .[ch] should be in a suitable subdirectory.

    $ git-ls-files | grep -v / | grep '\.[ch]$'
    arch_init.c
    balloon.c
    block.c
    blockdev-nbd.c
    blockdev.c
    blockjob.c
    bootdevice.c
    bt-host.c
    bt-vhci.c
    cpus-common.c
    cpus.c
    device-hotplug.c
    device_tree.c
    disas.c
    dma-helpers.c
    exec-vary.c
    exec.c
    gdbstub.c
    ioport.c
    iothread.c
    job-qmp.c
    job.c
    memory.c
    memory_ldst.inc.c
    memory_mapping.c
    module-common.c
    os-posix.c
    os-win32.c
    qdev-monitor.c
    qemu-bridge-helper.c
    qemu-edid.c
    qemu-img.c
    qemu-io-cmds.c
    qemu-io.c
    qemu-keymap.c
    qemu-nbd.c
    qemu-options-wrapper.h
    qemu-options.h
    qemu-seccomp.c
    qtest.c
    replication.c
    replication.h
    thunk.c
    tpm.c
    vl.c