bug#11912: 24.1; 'M' in Dired on a symlink does not refresh the display

[Michalis V.]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

> On a system that supports symlinks, do this:
>
>  emacs -Q
>  C-x d RET
>
> Go to any file and type
>
>  S foobar RET
>
> This creates a symlink named 'foobar' to the file on whose line you
> were when you typed S.  Now go to the line of 'foobar' and type this:
>
>  M 0444 RET
>
> Emacs says "Redisplaying...done", but the mode bits of the target of
> the symlink do not reflect the change.  Type 'g', and they will.
>
>>From a cursory look at the code (dired-do-redisplay), it sounds like
> Dired assumes that the file to be refreshed is necessarily on the
> current line (or marked).  This is false for symlinks and the 'M'
> command (and probably a few others, like 'O'), because the file that
> changes is the target of the symlink.
>
> I think this bug was in Emacs since about forever; I tried as far back
> as Emacs 22.1, and the problem was still there.


hi,

I can reproduce this in 27.1 but in 28.0.50 i get the following message:

Doing chmod: Operation not supported, /tmp/foobar

chmod on the symlinked file itself works ("Redisplaying..." too)

perhaps this functionality was disabled/removed for symlinks on purpose?
or is it a new bug?


Michalis