Re: Feature Request: Removal of '-f' Short Option in 'rm' Command

[Arsen Arsenović]

Owen Chia <aptx945@gmail.com> writes:

> Dear GNU Coreutils Team,
>
> I hope this email finds you well. I am writing to propose a feature request
> regarding the 'rm' command in GNU Coreutils. Specifically, I would like to
> suggest the removal of the '-f' short option, while retaining the '--force'
> long option.
>
> The rationale behind this proposal stems from the observation that the '-f'
> short option has led to numerous accidental deletions due to its ease of use
> and associated muscle memory. By removing the short option and encouraging the
> use of the longer '--force' option, we can mitigate such unintended
> consequences and promote safer usage of the 'rm' command.
>
> I believe that requiring users to type the full long option '--force' each 
> time
> they intend to forcefully remove files or directories would serve as an
> effective safeguard against inadvertent deletions. The additional effort
> involved in typing the longer option will create a deliberate pause, allowing
> users to consciously confirm their intent before proceeding with potentially
> irreversible actions.
>
> By implementing this change, we can prevent accidental data loss and promote a
> culture of cautious file management practices. The modification aligns with 
> the
> principles of user-friendly design and prioritizes the safety and integrity of
> user data.
>
> I kindly request the GNU Coreutils Team to consider this proposal for the 'rm'
> command. I understand that any changes to a widely used utility like Coreutils
> require careful consideration and testing. I am available to provide further
> insights, conduct additional testing, or assist in any way necessary to 
> support
> the implementation of this feature.

The idea is nice, and understandable, but POSIX requires '-f', so it's a
non-starter.

Have a lovely day.

> Thank you for your attention to this matter, and I look forward to your
> response. Your efforts in maintaining and improving the GNU Coreutils project
> are greatly appreciated.
>
> Sincerely,
> Owen Chia
> aptx945@gmail.org


-- 
Arsen Arsenović

signature.asc
Description: PGP signature