[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [DotGNU]Call for a truce over mono vs pnet
From: |
Adam Treat |
Subject: |
Re: [DotGNU]Call for a truce over mono vs pnet |
Date: |
Sun, 17 Mar 2002 20:04:38 -0800 |
> > I simply fail to understand why either project should sacrifice anything.
> > All things being equal (ie licenses) the Free Software world is supposed
> > to be about code-sharing without restriction as long as both parties
> > share and share alike. Right now, the relationship between Mono and pnet
> > is a one-way street, ie pnet can borrow Mono's code, but Mono can not
> > borrow pnet's. That's fine, since they are under different licenses, but
> > to insinuate that you'd change the license in exchange for Mono giving
> > something up... Well, that betrays the fact that your choice of license
> > isn't about philosophical licensing issues (which would be fine if that
> > were the case), but rather just a tool to leverage Mono to 'give
> > something up'.
>
> Our choice of license *IS* a philosophical issue.
>
> Quit jumping to convenient conclusions, please.
Fine. I'll take your word for it. I wasn't jumping to anything though. I
was correctly pointing out, that _if_ you use licensing as a bargaining tool,
_then_ your philosphical reasons for that license necessarily takes a back
seat to a 'what can I get for this' mentality.
Rhys, has since stated that he is not interested in bargaining like this.
Good for him.
Cheers,
Adam
Re: [DotGNU]Call for a truce over mono vs pnet, Adam Treat, 2002/03/17