[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist
From: |
Nomen Nescio |
Subject: |
Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist |
Date: |
Sat, 4 Mar 2017 12:14:19 +0100 (CET) |
Svetlana Tkachenko said:
> > > The software freedom principles apply to software only, not to
> > > organisations.
> > Principles (of any kind) are only endorsed or condemned by people
> > and organizations. An object or data (software) cannot reason
> > [...]
> That's what authorship is for. One program may have multiple
> authors, and one author may have multiple programs.
Authorship doesn't relieve copyright holders of free software duties.
There is no exclusion in free-sw.html for multiple authors of one
program, and no exclusion for authors that have multiple programs.
> The software freedom criteria correspond to the programs, not to the
> authors.
This has the same problem as your first claim. You've used a language
shortcut to remove /the people/ involved from their responsibility and
duty to comply with and uphold a principle.
Consequently, you've not addressed the arguments in the post you're
replying.
--
Please note this was sent anonymously, so the "From:" address will be unusable.
List archives will be monitored.
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Nomen Nescio, 2017/03/04
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist,
Nomen Nescio <=
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Anonymous, 2017/03/04
- Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Nomen Nescio, 2017/03/08
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Alfred M. Szmidt, 2017/03/09
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Jean Louis, 2017/03/09
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Mike Gerwitz, 2017/03/09
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Anonymous, 2017/03/09
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Mike Gerwitz, 2017/03/09
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Nomen Nescio, 2017/03/11
- Re: Freedom 0: the utilitarian vs. the deontologist, Mike Gerwitz, 2017/03/11