[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074)
From: |
Francisco Vila |
Subject: |
Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074) |
Date: |
Wed, 10 Aug 2011 17:35:27 +0200 |
2011/8/9 <address@hidden>:
> I'd make the tie slightly shorter. I find it awkward that two adjacent
> ties collide so easily, for example here
> {
> \time 3/4
> \relative c' { c2 e4 g2 e4 }
> \addlyrics { gran- de_a- mi- go }
> \addlyrics { pu- "ro y ho-" nes- to }
> \addlyrics { pu- ro~y~ho- nes- to }
> }
> (example from documentation), or in the example you attached on the
> tracker issue page.
I have never liked this example in the documentation.
Firstly, it seems to mix Portuguese and Spanish.
Secondly, it does not follow the policy for syllable separator, which
is '[space]--[space]', not '-[space]'.
Finally, 2nd and 3rd stanzas look _very_ improbable to me in that it
has three syllables on a single note, which requires two lyric ties.
o~y is a synalepha and it could be a in-word diphthong, y~ho is
another synalepha, but o~y~ho is not a triphthong and can not be a
three-vowel synalepha.
If nobody finds a real example in literature, I suggest to remove the
problematic case, it is too artificial.
--
Francisco Vila. Badajoz (Spain)
www.paconet.org , www.csmbadajoz.com
- Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), bordage . bertrand, 2011/08/06
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), lemzwerg, 2011/08/07
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), pkx166h, 2011/08/07
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), lemniskata . bernoullego, 2011/08/07
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), bordage . bertrand, 2011/08/08
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), pkx166h, 2011/08/08
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), lemniskata . bernoullego, 2011/08/08
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074),
Francisco Vila <=
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), bordage . bertrand, 2011/08/09
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), bordage . bertrand, 2011/08/10
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), Reinhold Kainhofer, 2011/08/10
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), Francisco Vila, 2011/08/10
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), Werner LEMBERG, 2011/08/11
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), Francisco Vila, 2011/08/11
- Re: Adds a glyph for tied lyrics. (issue4808074), Jean-Charles Malahieude, 2011/08/11