Re: [Emacs-diffs] master 4e23cd0 4/5: * mail/rmail.el (rmail-show-message-1): When displaying a mime message,

[Dmitry Gutov]

On 04/06/2015 10:54 AM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:

> Then please tell what you had in mind, perhaps it would be good to
> have that added.

I use 'git rebase -i' for that. Not sure if we actually want to mention 
rebasing in the instructions.

But if not, should they recommend reviewing each commit right away after 
it's made?

> In my book it's an understandable position of a busy person who wants
> a simple job of making an upstream change to "just work".  Such people
> _will_ learn with good help, but much slower.

Well, here's hoping. IME, Git is better learned from fundamentals, but 
hopefully these careful instructions will make it easier for people to 
ignore the former, without major consequences.

> I think you fail to understand how humiliating that would be.  That's
> okay, let's talk in, say, 30 years, and see where you stand then ;-)

I'd call that delegating, and I'm sure many people would be okay with 
it. But of course, if there's a similar motivated individual 30 years 
from now to write a new guide, that would be great too.

> When someone is in grave trouble, what do you expect?  He can be
> taught fishing after he's out of trouble, but not before.  You don't
> start teaching people how to avoid a fire before putting the fire out.

Being hungry is the best motivation to learn fishing. And as we know 
now, his situation was fairly normal: a history containing two normal 
local commits and lagging behind the remote master otherwise.

So what was needed is a pull, a merge resolving the conflicts, and then 
a push. The situation was complicated by the need to resolve ChangeLog 
conflicts manually (or else there may have been no conflicts at all), 
which is something that was a problem for me as well after Emacs's 
transition to Git. While I know how to merge, it wasn't obvious how 
exactly those kind of conflicts should be resolved, which ordering to 
use, dates, etc. And it's annoying to have to do it each time manually.