[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments
From: |
Trevor Daniels |
Subject: |
Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments |
Date: |
Tue, 8 Apr 2008 11:01:10 +0100 |
Karl Hammar wrote
Till:
8.5 Transcription of ancient music
Why not call it "Editing" or "Making an edition", but transcription is
also fine.
I think we'll stick with "Transcription" - it seems closer to the action
being performed by those working with ancient music, who usually
want to preserve the original as faithfully as possible, rather than
editing it.
5.2 Incipits and Mensurstriche-layout
Theese are different beasts, should they not be in seperate sections.
I'm out of my depth here. Anyone else have an opinion?
I'm quite happy to make this into two sections if there is
something different to write about each of them.
5.4 Musica ficta
5.4.1 Suggested accidentals (new) (2.8.4)
This has already been changed to just
5.4 Musica ficta accidentals
(containing just the current text from 2.8.4)
Instead of Musica ficta, which are notes not in the regular hexachords,
I suggests a section for editorial markings. Which includes suggested
accidentals, slurs, different rhythmic (like french barock)
interpretation.
Happy to add Editorial markings for ancient music as an additional
section, incorporating 5.4, if someone volunteers to send me suitable
text for it, but I can't write this stuff myself :(
Regards,
/Karl
Trevor D
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, (continued)
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Till, 2008/04/06
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Trevor Daniels, 2008/04/06
- Re: Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, till Rettig, 2008/04/07
- Re: Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Trevor Daniels, 2008/04/07
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Till Rettig, 2008/04/07
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Trevor Daniels, 2008/04/07
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Till Rettig, 2008/04/07
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Karl Hammar, 2008/04/07
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Trevor Daniels, 2008/04/08
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Karl Hammar, 2008/04/07
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments,
Trevor Daniels <=
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Karl Hammar, 2008/04/08
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Trevor Daniels, 2008/04/08
- Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Mats Bengtsson, 2008/04/08
Fw: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments, Trevor Daniels, 2008/04/08