[Top][All Lists]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments

From: Karl Hammar
Subject: Re: GDP: Reorganisation of NR 2 - Final call for comments
Date: Tue, 8 Apr 2008 00:21:32 +0200 (CEST)

Sorry for coming in late in the game.

>  8.5 Transcription of ancient music

Why not call it "Editing" or "Making an edition", but transcription is 
also fine.

>  5.1 using the same source for the original and the transcription [Here 
> among others the snippets about reducing note length] 
> 5.2 Incipits and Mensurstriche-layout

Theese are different beasts, should they not be in seperate sections.
> 5.3 Transcription of Gregorian chant
> 5.4 Musica ficta
> 5.4.1 Suggested accidentals (new) (2.8.4) 
>   Something like that, please reformulate as you like, I am really bad in 
> creating headings.

Instead of Musica ficta, which are notes not in the regular hexachords, 
I suggests a section for editorial markings. Which includes suggested 
accidentals, slurs, different rhythmic (like french barock) 
interpretation. Also you don't want to rule out b _flat_ as an suggestion.
Bes is not an ficta note since it is available in the hexachord, thus 
it is musica recta.


reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]